Testimonials

I recently started working in Brick and some of my clients have told me about this bakery, specifically the key lime pie, so when I needed to get a cake for my employee I decided to take the trip. I am so glad that I did! The key lime pie is nothing short of divine, best I've ever had. And my employee absolutely loved the cake. I will 10000% be back

Katy N.

★★★★★

I've been loyal to 502 for years now; hands down the most delicious baked goods around. We've tried almost everything and it's always so fresh and so delicious; you can taste the love that it's prepared with. Our top favorites: chicken pot pie (best I've ever had ) , eclairs, cheese crumb is a staple in our home, donuts, cupcakes, chocolate crème pie and on Mother's Day we had the edible chocolate cups with raspberry or cannoli filling, they went so fast I couldn't even take a picture. I highly recommend them. The store is clean and the employees are incredible If you haven't tried it you must! Thank you for all of your amazing goodies.

LeeAnn V.

Just spotted this absolute gem!! Stopped in to order their famous carrot cake for my colleague's work anniversary, and got a Key Lime Bite for myself. Key Lime is my FAVORITE, and I order it whenever I see it on a dessert menu. Well, this was the BEST I've ever had, hands down!! I will be stopping in here on the regular from now on! Friendly, helpful staff, too! Give them a try, you won't be disappointed.

Camille C.

★★★★★

Great tasting baked goods, vegan option too!
Thanks for making our daughter's baby shower a success! The cupcake 'cake' was beautiful and VERY tasty! Support locally owned family business, especially if you LOVE key lime! :)

Roberto C.

★★★★★

THE BEST BAKERY IN 50 MILES! Staff is so generous, kind and helpful no matter what you need. Everything is delicious but the chicken pot pie right now is divine ?

Kim J.

★★★★★

Just picked up a freshly baked key lime pie after having tasted it last night for dessert at the Atlantic Market Restaurant in Point Pleasant. Along with my husband we met the owners who turned out to be not only talented but also the nicest couple ever. We will definitely come back for more and also to taste the other items. We highly recommend this hidden gem in Brick NJ.

Maria A.

★★★★★

Amazing!!!!!!!! Incredible!!!!!! Best key lime pie I have ever tasted..so fresh!!! Cheese crumb is to die for! And the staff and owner are just the nicest! Must try!!

Victoria T.

★★★★★

Excellent for those with allergies! I cannot have gluten and dairy and was able to get a gluten and dairy free birthday cake and pumpkin pie! Both tasted amazing!

Jenna C.

★★★★★

It is not surprising to hear that people drive hours to come to 502! The smell....OMG...the smell!! Their baked goods are unmatched! I love supporting this small business! Everything I have had has been amazing, but I love, love, love the cheese crumb (photo)! The owners and staff are extremely friendly and helpful! You won't be disappointed!

Kristen T.

★★★★★

The pies are incredible, I've tried them all. The brownies are some of the best I've eaten. If you remember Ebinger's bakery from Brooklyn try their Black out cake ,needs to be pre order but it's worth the wait.

John D.

Best bakery in the area by far. Always end up buying more than we planned - everything is so good. Friendly and helpful staff. We found them at the Brick Farmers Market and now are regulars at the store.

Darrell G.

★★★★★

Dear lord these doughnuts!!!!! I liked the key lime bites, I truly did, my only problem was the crust was only on the bottom and quite a but got stuck to the paper so I had to lock it clean!! LMAO It's truly a non-issue. And the couple running the place was so incredibly friendly. Next time I'll get the full key lime pie!

Paul C.

★★★★★

Oh My Heavens...BEST gluten free brownies far & wide. They are dense, chewy & oh so very chocolatey. Pure heaven. Thank you.

Tamara M.

★★★★★

I visited 502 this morning for the first time. The owner, Toni, went above and beyond to make certain my grandchildren would have the area's best donuts for breakfast. Her service was wonderful and the products were delicious. I highly recommend 502.

Joseph B.

I ordered three dozen unicorn cupcakes for my daughter's 2nd birthday party from 502 Baking Company. As a mom of 2 under 2, I didn't really have time to put much thought into what they would look like, but 502 Baking Company took the idea and ran with it! They came out absolutely perfect! Everyone was super impressed with how they looked as well as how they tasted. I tried all three flavors I ordered and the vanilla cupcakes were the best I have ever had! I'm hosting another event in a few weeks and will be going back to 502 Baking Company for the desserts. I'm also going to order pies for Thanksgiving. Everyone there is so nice and accommodating. I love that I found my new go-to local bakery!

Jennifer R.

★★★★★

The best baked goods next to my mother in-laws talent! Exceptional quality ingredients and so fresh! I have never tasted anything better! Want to make a slash at a party? Just txt or call 502 Bakery Co!

Stephanie Zecca

★★★★★

My wife and I love Key Lime pie, so much so we've had it shipped from Florida. No more! Toni at 502 Bakery is a master, and super friendly and accommodating to boot. If you love Key Lime pie, this is THE place on the Jersey Shore. Highly recommend!

Tom G.

★★★★★

Another gem of a place. Warm greetings and warm cakes and pastries leave you with a warm heart and a belly full of finger-licking sweets. A must try!

R. C.

★★★★★

What a great find! Awesome key lime pie! A great gluten free carrot cake for our daughter's birthday cake, we all loved it and the owner and staff were super friendly. ❤

Louann A.

★★★★★

Tremendously delicious keylime pie??????
Buttery Graham cracker crust & just the right tartness of pie. Been having keylime for years in The Florida Keys. 502 Baking Company ranks very high & is definitely competition. Thank you for the last minute Birthday wishes you offered to write on the pie. Customer service AND great pie ???

Leslie S.

★★★★★

Their Tiramisu is the best I ever had! Love the flourless chocolate cake and the scones. Have yet to be disappointed by anything I have tried. Love that they support local artist Kristin Tozer and her amazing Sea Glass Jewelry!

Heather C.

★★★★★

Thank you for the delicious Vanilla cake. Everyone enjoyed it & were unaware it was dairy & gluten free!!

Constance R.

★★★★★

Just tried the Key lime pie and it was delicious, possibly the best I ever tasted. My wife had the apple turnover and enjoyed it. I look forward to trying more of their items!

Stephen R.

★★★★★

Excellent pies, cakes, try their chicken pot pies when they have them outstanding!!!!

Frances A.

★★★★★

I ordered a cake for a Sunday and they had it ready on short notice and they also helped me put it in my car. The cake was delicious and I highly recommend them for your baking needs.

Paul C.

★★★★★

My daughter surprised me with a vegan birthday cake from here and it was outstanding! I'm so super impressed that they were able to do it in short notice and it was delicious!

Maya S.

★★★★★

Amazing pies and the nicest owner. The peanut butter pie is incredible and soooo home made. An amazing find!! Loved it!

Jason B.

★★★★★

Great gluten free selection.
And EVERYTHING else is beautiful and delightful!!
Nice little bakery, friendly staff.

Lorraine F.

★★★★★

The best key lime pie ever. The cheese crumb cake is absolutely delicious. Will be going back

Deborah C.

★★★★★

OMG, the chocolate cream pie and the key lime pie is out of this world!!! The staff and the owner are so nice too!

Chris D.

★★★★★

Everything is fresh and delicious, made in small batches so when it's gone it's gone! Good good Good!

ROSEANN M.

★★★★★